Table of contents

Understanding the average car insurance rates can be crucial for optimizing your budget and finding the best coverage for your needs. Car insurance rates can vary depending on multiple factors, such as your location, driving history, and the type of vehicle you own. 

By staying informed about the average rates in your area and exploring ways to optimize your budget, you can make smarter decisions when it comes to car insurance. In this article, we will delve into the average car insurance rates and provide tips to help you maximize your coverage while minimizing costs.

Revving up your budget: Unveiling the average car insurance rates

When it comes to car insurance, understanding the average rates for various coverage levels can help you make informed decisions about your policy. 

 

Table: Average car insurance rates by coverage level
Coverage Level Average Annual Premium Average Monthly Premium
State Minimum Liability Only $ 483 $ 40
50/100/50 Liability Only $ 603 $ 50
100/300/100 Liability with $500 Comp/Coll Deductible $ 1,607 $ 134

The table above highlights the average annual and monthly premiums for different levels of coverage. As expected, the higher the coverage level, the higher the premium. Interestingly, upgrading from state minimum liability only to 50/100/50 liability only increases the average monthly premium by just $10, while opting for 100/300/100 liability with a $500 comprehensive/collision deductible raises it to $134 per month. 

From teenagers to seniors: Exploring the average car insurance rates by age of driver

Age plays a significant role in determining car insurance premiums. As the data shows, younger drivers face the highest rates, with 16-year-olds paying a staggering $7,096 on average annually. This can be attributed to their lack of driving experience and higher risk of accidents. 

However, as drivers age and gain experience, their rates decline significantly. By the time drivers reach 25, they see an average annual premium of $1,958, which is a 72% reduction from their rates at 16. Rates continue to decrease, reaching their lowest point at age 60, before rising again as drivers enter their senior years.

Table: Car insurance rates by age of driver
Age Average Annual Premium
16 $ 7,096
17 $ 5,838
18 $ 5,149
19 $ 3,883
20 $ 3,497
21 $ 2,826
22 $ 2,575
23 $ 2,370
24 $ 2,215
25 $ 1,958
30 $ 1,716
35 $ 1,657
40 $ 1,607
45 $ 1,579
50 $ 1,520
55 $ 1,476
60 $ 1,465
65 $ 1,520
70 $ 1,616
75 $ 1,790

Gender impact on car insurance rates: Are there disparities in average car insurance rates

The data reveals some interesting insights into the gender-based disparities in car insurance rates. On average, male drivers pay more than their female counterparts across all age groups. The most significant difference appears among teenage drivers, with 16-year-old males paying an average of $811 (12.8%) more annually than females of the same age. 

The gap narrows as drivers age, with the difference being just $14 (0.9%) for 60-year-olds. This suggests that insurance providers consider young male drivers to be riskier and therefore charge higher premiums.

Table: Average car insurance rates by gender
Age Average rates for Female Average rates for Male
16 $ 6,285 $ 7,096
17 $ 5,168 $ 5,838
18 $ 4,531 $ 5,149
19 $ 3,393 $ 3,883
20 $ 3,073 $ 3,497
21 $ 2,523 $ 2,826
22 $ 2,335 $ 2,575
23 $ 2,176 $ 2,370
24 $ 2,061 $ 2,215
25 $ 1,869 $ 1,958
30 $ 1,702 $ 1,716
35 $ 1,659 $ 1,657
40 $ 1,614 $ 1,607
45 $ 1,585 $ 1,579
50 $ 1,516 $ 1,520
55 $ 1,466 $ 1,476
60 $ 1,451 $ 1,465
65 $ 1,491 $ 1,520
70 $ 1,572 $ 1,616
75 $ 1,706 $ 1,790

State-by-State comparison: Where car insurance rates are the highest and lowest

Car insurance rates can vary significantly from state to state due to various factors. Let’s compare where car insurance rates tend to be the highest and lowest across different states:

Table: Car insurance cost by state
State State Minimum Liability Only 50/100/50 Liability Only 100/300/100 Liability with $500 Comp/Coll Deductible
Alaska $ 336 $ 414 $ 1,359
Alabama $ 372 $ 520 $ 1,442
Arkansas $ 349 $ 428 $ 1,420
Arizona $ 452 $ 636 $ 1,484
California $ 578 $ 853 $ 2,110
Colorado $ 437 $ 705 $ 1,804
Connecticut $ 751 $ 834 $ 1,741
Washington D.C. $ 577 $ 663 $ 1,858
Delaware $ 835 $ 1,022 $ 2,111
Florida $ 878 $ 1,536 $ 2,517
Georgia $ 504 $ 626 $ 1,555
Hawaii $ 389 $ 519 $ 1,306
Iowa $ 263 $ 318 $ 1,321
Idaho $ 294 $ 352 $ 1,052
Illinois $ 423 $ 471 $ 1,384
Indiana $ 346 $ 400 $ 1,184
Kansas $ 380 $ 405 $ 1,526
Kentucky $ 579 $ 766 $ 1,864
Louisiana $ 623 $ 1,147 $ 2,487
Massachusetts $ 534 $ 653 $ 1,528
Maryland $ 580 $ 618 $ 1,504
Maine $ 338 $ 342 $ 1,122
Michigan $ 731 $ 778 $ 2,158
Minnesota $ 475 $ 511 $ 1,482
Missouri $ 484 $ 553 $ 1,984
Mississippi $ 406 $ 551 $ 1,498
Montana $ 343 $ 482 $ 1,751
North Carolina $ 385 $ 424 $ 1,324
North Dakota $ 329 $ 344 $ 1,295
Nebraska $ 321 $ 355 $ 1,976
New Hampshire $ 395 $ 430 $ 1,266
New Jersey $ 994 $ 1,134 $ 1,910
New Mexico $ 372 $ 546 $ 1,509
Nevada $ 655 $ 976 $ 1,969
New York $ 875 $ 960 $ 2,020
Ohio $ 287 $ 345 $ 996
Oklahoma $ 329 $ 509 $ 1,692
Oregon $ 535 $ 580 $ 1,217
Pennsylvania $ 315 $ 410 $ 1,256
Rhode Island $ 593 $ 736 $ 1,717
South Carolina $ 628 $ 793 $ 1,894
South Dakota $ 267 $ 289 $ 1,581
Tennessee $ 329 $ 409 $ 1,311
Texas $ 509 $ 630 $ 1,794
Utah $ 501 $ 619 $ 1,414
Virginia $ 444 $ 457 $ 1,227
Vermont $ 285 $ 315 $ 1,102
Washington $ 443 $ 584 $ 1,203
Wisconsin $ 324 $ 365 $ 1,325
West Virginia $ 430 $ 486 $ 1,528
Wyoming $ 288 $ 328 $ 1,659

Several factors influence car insurance rates, including:

1. State laws: Each state has different regulations and requirements that can impact insurance rates. Factors like minimum coverage limits, mandatory no-fault insurance, and state-specific laws affect pricing.

2. Population density: Highly populated states often have higher rates due to increased traffic, higher chances of accidents, and more insurance claims.

3. Traffic and accident rates: States with high traffic congestion and accident rates generally experience higher insurance premiums.

4. Frequency of vehicle theft: Areas with higher rates of vehicle theft may have increased insurance costs due to the risk of theft and property damage claims.  

Remember, these are general trends, and individual factors like driving record, age, and vehicle type also impact insurance rates. It’s essential to compare quotes from multiple insurance providers and consider your unique circumstances when selecting car insurance coverage.

CompuTips

The Role of ZIP Codes: Insurance companies consider ZIP codes when determining rates. Factors such as population density, crime rates, and historical accident data in your area can impact premiums. Even moving to a neighboring ZIP code can result in different rates, so it’s worth comparing quotes when relocating.

Top 10 Most expensive states for car insurance

Several states tend to have higher car insurance rates, including:

  1. Florida: Florida’s high population, frequent severe weather events, and high rates of uninsured drivers contribute to elevated insurance costs. The full coverage in Florida costs $2,517 per year. 
  2. Louisiana: Full coverage car insurance costs $2,487 per year. The state’s high accident rates, litigation frequency, and insurance fraud contribute to higher insurance premiums.
  3. Michigan: Known for having the highest average car insurance premiums due to factors like unlimited Personal Injury Protection (PIP) coverage and high healthcare costs. Drivers in Michigan pay $2,158 per year for full coverage. 

Delaware, with its densely populated areas, experiences increased traffic and a greater likelihood of accidents, leading to elevated insurance costs. California’s high population density, coupled with the prevalence of expensive vehicles, drives up insurance rates in the state. New York, known for its bustling urban areas and heavy traffic, sees higher premiums as a result.

Table: Most expensive states for full coverage
State Full Coverage Rates (100/300/100)
Florida $ 2,517
Louisiana $ 2,487
Michigan $ 2,158
Delaware $ 2,111
California $ 2,110
New York $ 2,020
Missouri $ 1,984
Nebraska $ 1,976
Nevada $ 1,969
New Jersey $ 1,910

Top 10 Least expensive states for car insurance

On the other end of the spectrum, some states generally have lower car insurance rates, including:

  1. Ohio: Known for its competitive insurance market and lower accident rates, Ohio often offers more affordable insurance options. Full coverage insurance in Ohio costs $996 per year. 
  2. Idaho: with its lower population density and fewer traffic congestion issues, enjoys lower insurance costs. Drivers in Idaho pay $1,052 per year for full coverage. 
  3. Vermont: With its rural nature and fewer traffic congestions, Vermont tends to have lower insurance rates.Car insurance rates for full coverage in Vermont is $1,102 per year. 

Idaho, Vermont, Maine, Indiana, Washington, Oregon, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and New Hampshire also have relatively low average premiums, ranging from $1,052 to $1,266.

States like Vermont and Maine benefit from their rural nature, which translates into lower premiums. Indiana’s robust insurance market and fewer incidents of uninsured drivers contribute to its favorable rates.

Table: Least expensive states for full coverage
State Full Coverage Cost(100/300/100)
Ohio $ 996
Idaho $ 1,052
Vermont $ 1,102
Maine $ 1,122
Indiana $ 1,184
Washington $ 1,203
Oregon $ 1,217
Virginia $ 1,227
Pennsylvania $ 1,256
New Hampshire $ 1,266

Vroom or gloom: Analyzing car insurance rates by vehicle type

Apart from geographical location and state-specific factors, the type of vehicle you own also plays a significant role in determining insurance rates.

Vehicle Type Average Annual Premium
Coupe $ 2,578
Minivan $ 1,694
Pick-up $ 1,569
Sedan $ 2,131
SUV $ 1,765
Van $ 1,512
Car $ 2,127
Truck $ 1,780
Van $ 1,560

Table: Car insurance cost by vehicle type

Let’s dive into the analysis of car insurance rates by vehicle type.

Coupes are found to have the highest average annual premium at $2,578. The sporty nature and higher performance of coupes often lead to increased risks and repair costs, resulting in elevated insurance rates. On the other hand, minivans prove to be the least expensive to insure, with an average premium of $1,694. Minivans are generally considered safer due to their family-oriented design and are involved in fewer accidents, leading to lower insurance costs.

Pick-ups and vans fall into the affordable category as well, with average premiums of $1,569 and $1,512, respectively. These vehicles often have lower repair costs and are associated with fewer claims, contributing to their favourable insurance rates. 

Sedans and SUVs share a similar average premium range, with sedans slightly higher at $2,131 and SUVs at $1,765. Sedans may have a higher risk of theft, while SUVs are popular among families and tend to have lower repair costs. Finally, trucks have an average premium of $1,780, reflecting their relatively lower risk profile.

CompuTips

Impact of Vehicle Modifications: Modifying your vehicle, such as installing performance enhancements or aftermarket parts, can affect your insurance rates. These modifications may increase the value of your car or make it more attractive to thieves, resulting in higher premiums. Notify your insurer about any modifications to ensure proper coverage.

Choosing the right insurance provider: Average car insurance rates by company

The table below presents average car insurance rates offered by different insurance providers for various liability coverage limits. It is essential to analyze this data to make an informed decision on choosing the best insurance provider that suits your budget and requirements.

 

Table: Average car insurance cost by company for different coverage levels
Company Group State Minimum Liability Only 50/100/50 Liability Only 100/300/100 Liability with $500 Comp/Coll Deductible
Allstate $ 555 $ 668 $ 2,086
American Family $ 563 $ 625 $ 1,362
American National Finance $ 187 $ 229 $ 857
Amica Mutual $ 446 $ 528 $ 1,341
Arbella Insurance $ 483 $ 639 $ 1,696
Auto Club Enterprises (AAA) $ 517 $ 720 $ 1,953
Automobile Club MI (AAA) $ 533 $ 584 $ 2,443
Auto-Owners $ 355 $ 445 $ 1,406
Chubb Ltd $ 372 $ 454 $ 2,479
Country Financial $ 453 $ 709 $ 2,017
CSAA Insurance (AAA) $ 525 $ 741 $ 2,453
Erie Insurance $ 334 $ 386 $ 1,254
Farmers $ 632 $ 856 $ 1,980
Frankenmuth Insurance $ 302 $ 308 $ 1,339
Geico $ 326 $ 423 $ 1,266
Iowa Farm Bureau $ 305 $ 496 $ 2,369
Island Insurance $ 415 $ 535 $ 1,668
Kemper Insurance $ 694 $ 869 $ 2,422
Kentucky Farm Bureau $ 432 $ 614 $ 2,204
Mapfre Insurance $ 270 $ 302 $ 1,091
Mercury Insurance $ 719 $ 916 $ 2,167
National General Insurance $ 786 $ 1,223 $ 2,397
Nationwide $ 495 $ 589 $ 1,190
New Jersey Manufacturers $ 494 $ 585 $ 1,284
North Carolina Farm Bureau $ 353 $ 395 $ 1,218
Oklahoma Farm Bureau $ 509 $ 774 $ 2,642
Palisades $ 535 $ 638 $ 1,073
Progressive $ 551 $ 682 $ 1,686
Safety Insurance $ 426 $ 539 $ 1,226
Safeway Insurance $ 1,075 $ 1,509 $ 2,810
Sentry Insurance $ 1,588 $ 2,106 $ 4,803
Shelter Insurance $ 530 $ 719 $ 1,840
Southern Farm Bureau $ 333 $ 656 $ 1,478
State Farm $ 432 $ 545 $ 1,436
The Hanover $ 1,601 $ 1,801 $ 4,350
The Hartford $ 623 $ 861 $ 2,341
Travelers $ 531 $ 642 $ 1,488
USAA $ 294 $ 369 $ 1,192
Vermont Mutual $ 231 $ 285 $ 1,172
Western National Mutual $ 355 $ 466 $ 1,517
Westfield Insurance $ 394 $ 475 $ 1,806

Let’s dive into the table and do some calculations to find out which companies offer the most budget-friendly options.

When it comes to state minimum liability only, the top 3 cheapest insurance providers are:

  1. Western National Mutual – $355
  2. Auto-Owners – $355
  3. North Carolina Farm Bureau – $353

For 50/100/50 liability only coverage, the best options are:

  1. Erie Insurance – $386
  2. Western National Mutual – $466
  3. Geico – $423

Lastly, for 100/300/100 liability coverage with a $500 comp/coll deductible, the most budget-friendly providers are:

  1. USAA* – $1,192
  2. Nationwide – $1,190
  3. Vermont Mutual – $1,172

Note: USAA only offers car insurance to military members, veterans and their family members. 

It’s important to note that the table does not account for factors such as your age, location, driving history, or vehicle type, which can significantly impact your insurance rates. Therefore, these numbers should be considered as a general guideline.

Budget-friendly options: Finding the cheapest car insurance rates

Car insurance is a necessary expense, but that doesn’t mean you have to break the bank. According to the recent data, American National Finance offers the cheapest full coverage car insurance at $857 per year. 

Here is a list of insurance provides who offer budget-friendly car insurance rates

Table: Cheapest companies offering full coverage car insurance
Company 100/300/100 Liability with $500 Comp/Coll Deductible
American National Finance $ 857
Palisades $ 1,073
Mapfre Insurance $ 1,091
Vermont Mutual $ 1,172
Nationwide $ 1,190
USAA $ 1,192
North Carolina Farm Bureau $ 1,218
Safety Insurance $ 1,226
Erie Insurance $ 1,254
Geico $ 1,266
New Jersey Manufacturers $ 1,284
Frankenmuth Insurance $ 1,339
Amica Mutual $ 1,341
American Family $ 1,362
Auto-Owners $ 1,406
State Farm $ 1,436
Southern Farm Bureau $ 1,478
Travelers $ 1,488
Western National Mutual $ 1,517
Island Insurance $ 1,668
Progressive $ 1,686
Arbella Insurance $ 1,696
Westfield Insurance $ 1,806
Shelter Insurance $ 1,840
Auto Club Enterprises (AAA) $ 1,953
Farmers $ 1,980
Country Financial $ 2,017
Allstate $ 2,086
Mercury Insurance $ 2,167
Kentucky Farm Bureau $ 2,204
The Hartford $ 2,341
Iowa Farm Bureau $ 2,369
National General Insurance $ 2,397
Kemper Insurance $ 2,422
Automobile Club MI (AAA) $ 2,443
CSAA Insurance (AAA) $ 2,453
Chubb Ltd $ 2,479
Oklahoma Farm Bureau $ 2,642
Safeway Insurance $ 2,810
The Hanover $ 4,350
Sentry Insurance $ 4,803

Here are some tips to save more on car insurance:

  • Shop around and compare – Don’t settle for the first car insurance quote you receive. Take the time to shop around and compare rates from different insurance providers. Online comparison tools can help you easily compare prices and coverage options to find the best deal.
  • Consider higher deductibles – Opting for a higher deductible can lower your insurance premium. Just make sure you can afford to pay the deductible in case of an accident or claim.
  • Evaluate your coverage needs – Assess your coverage needs and consider adjusting your policy accordingly. If you have an older car with a low market value, you might not need comprehensive and collision coverage, which can be costly. However, be cautious not to sacrifice necessary coverage to save a few bucks.
  • Look for discounts – Insurance companies offer various discounts that can help reduce your premium. Common discounts include good driver discounts, bundling auto and home insurance, low mileage discounts, and discounts for safety features in your vehicle. Inquire about these discounts and see if you qualify for any.
  • Maintain a good driving record – Safe driving habits can lead to lower insurance rates. Avoid speeding tickets, accidents, and other traffic violations, as they can increase your premiums. Over time, maintaining a clean driving record can help you secure better rates.
  • Consider usage-based insurance – Usage-based insurance programs monitor your driving habits, such as mileage, speed, and braking patterns, using telematics devices or smartphone apps. By demonstrating responsible driving behavior, you may qualify for lower premiums.

Remember, while it’s important to find affordable car insurance, make sure you’re not sacrificing necessary coverage or excellent customer service. Review policies carefully, understand the terms and conditions, and choose a reputable insurance provider that offers both affordability and reliability. 

Frequently asked questions about car insurance cost

How can I accurately estimate my own car insurance rates based on the average rates for my region and personal circumstances?

Accurately estimating your car insurance rates based on average rates for your region and personal circumstances can be done through a few simple steps. 

  • Start by researching average rates specific to your area and take note of any factors that may impact premiums, such as age, gender, driving history, and vehicle type. 
  • Utilize online tools or insurance providers’ websites to obtain personalized quotes based on your unique situation. 

These quotes will give you a better understanding of the potential costs you can expect. Remember to provide accurate and detailed information to ensure the estimates align closely with your circumstances.

How can my driving history and record impact the average car insurance rates I’m likely to encounter?

Your driving history and record play a crucial role in determining your car insurance rates. If you have a clean record with no accidents or traffic violations, you’re more likely to enjoy lower rates. On the other hand, a history of accidents or speeding tickets may result in higher premiums. Insurance companies assess risk, so maintaining a safe driving record can help keep your rates down.

Can I negotiate or renegotiate my car insurance rates to optimize my budget?

While negotiating car insurance rates directly may not be common, you can still optimize your budget by shopping around and comparing quotes from different providers. Use the average rates as a reference point and leverage competitive pricing. Additionally, if you’ve had significant life changes or improvements in your driving habits, inform your insurance company. They may be willing to review your rates and make adjustments accordingly.

How often should I review my car insurance policy to ensure I’m getting the best rates?

It’s essential to review your car insurance policy periodically, ideally once a year, to ensure you’re still getting the best rates and coverage. Changes in your circumstances, such as moving to a new area or purchasing a different vehicle, can affect your rates. Additionally, advancements in technology or changes in insurance regulations may introduce new options or discounts. By reviewing your policy regularly, you can make informed decisions to optimize your budget and ensure you have adequate coverage.

Conclusion

Understanding the average car insurance rates is essential for optimizing your budget and finding the right coverage for your needs. Factors such as location, age, gender, and vehicle type can significantly impact insurance premiums. 

By comparing quotes from multiple providers and considering your unique circumstances, you can make informed decisions to maximize your coverage while minimizing costs. It’s important to note that rates vary from state to state, with Florida, Louisiana, and Michigan being among the most expensive states for car insurance, while Ohio, Idaho, and Vermont are relatively more affordable.

Ultimately, staying informed and exploring options can help you make the most cost-effective choices for your car insurance.

About the Author: CompuQuotes Editorial
b6242ae3b0473f9443e5a51cdd6eb1da?s=72&d=mm&r=g
Get smart about saving money on insurance